Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Technology in Schools

I have written essays on Technology and its effects multiple times, but sometimes technology gets to me. Why is it necessary for young children to have iPads in kindergarten, or their own laptops even? http://www.voanews.com/learningenglish/home/education/A-School-System-in-Maine-Gives-iPads-to-Kindergartners-134428658.html 
Growing up there was no need for each student to have their own electronic device to learn skills from, the world has done fine without the extensive use of technology up until now. I do understand however that students will get "immediate" feedback from some of the programs and apps that are on the devices, and that it may help the teacher know exactly what to help the students with specifically, but what about reading and writing? A child cannot simply just sit in front of an iPad all day to learn every skill that needs to be learned. 
Also, it peeves me to think about how much money was spent on these devices for each individual student, this money did not come from extra spending money the district had, but instead from the pockets of tax payers. Not only did plenty of parents pay for this learning material, but do all of the parents approve? Did they do a vote with the community to see if this idea was the best? I am confused and would really be interested in hearing about how many parents approve of this and why exactly they do.
Last semester in my Eng 101 class, we read an article about Waldorf Schools, which are schools that do not allow technology to be used as a means of learning. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/23/technology/at-waldorf-school-in-silicon-valley-technology-can-wait.html?pagewanted=all Many children that are enrolled in these schools have parents that are involved in making and using the new technologies everyday of their lives. The schools that these children go to may be very intense but children learn so quickly that using technology in the future should be no problem for them.
So why is it that so many schools are jumping right in with the new technology so quickly? What about the fun games that students used to play to learn like matching, singing, painting, or writing their own short stories? I am worried that many good traits will be gone if educators start to become dependent on technology to teach their students. It is not so simple to just hand a child a device and say "here, learn." Hands on and real life I believe is more important, there is no need for the extra bit when children have learned very well without all the extra technology in the past.
Overall, there will be some advantages to having the technology available in the classroom, but it should not be used too much, students should be social and talk about what they are learning instead. Small learning games are normal on computers but if the computer is teaching the student how to learn, then why even have a teacher? Technology needs to have restrictions, and giving 5 year olds their own iPad is a little much for a school to take on.

8 comments:

  1. I could not agree more with Emily. I had to help my Uncle find an Ipad for my 8 year old nephew, and I just couldn’t believe that at 7 or 8 years old a kid wants an Ipad. At that age I used to ask for new action figures or a new scooter, but not a computer. The age of the “Electronic Mob” is seeping into all cracks of society, and that includes the classroom. In regards to our last essay, we had talked about education today and before the Internet. Emily’s blog represents my point of view that I took on my paper perfectly. As Siegel says, all the learning with technology these kids are doing today would be accomplished or worked out just as well if there was no Internet or Ipads. That is why I am dumfounded to witness the day that kids who can barely read are using laptops and Ipads as a means to learn and play games. Maybe it is because I am old-fashioned, but at the age these kids are at technology and the Internet should be at the back of their minds. This just goes to show the solitary lifestyle kids are beginning to live today between video games and the Internet, they feel no need to go outside and play. Obesity, unsociable, and any other issue I feel can be linked to the increased dependence on technology with young kids today.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree Emily; I have no idea that kids were required to have iPads in such a young age, that’s unbelievable. What happen to our society? I remember like it was yesterday, when I was in kinder garden, there was no source of technology for us to use at all. Teachers were all the resources we need to learn the information, now we have things such as iPads and iPods that have tarnished our ability to learn simple math and reading skills. Children between the ages 7-10 should not be asking for such a powerful tool that they do not need yet. By having new technologies like this, teachers are now becoming lazy because they can depend on computers then the degree they received from college. That’s just crazy in my opinion. As a young kid, you were always able to enjoy class by how the teacher interacts with the kids. Maybe by having fun activities using the chalk board or drawing pictures. There is no need to use iPads to help kids learn or how to read or do math. These parents need to think about their children’s future. I know they want the best education for them but that’s not the way to go.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I totally agree. When we were kids, we were able to learn the old fashion way. I think that this was way more efficient then what they are doing today. When kids use technology to learn there are many more distractions in the learning process, such as games, music and many more. Also I agree with the paying part. Why do the schools need to teach with such an expensive product? What was wrong with the way before, what worked for many years before? Nothing, it’s just making it easier for the teachers to teach. Also I think that this is a bad thing because of the lack of creativity that the young students possess today. Today these electronic devices such as ipads that are given to these kids do many things for you. If you want to make a game the device will develop it for you, as opposed to before when you needed to make it yourself and color and draw. Even being a college student I think that a computer is partially hurtful to the learning. If kids only know how to do things with the device they will have a hard time in the future, standing out from one another.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I understand your point of view, when you say technology in education is too much for the elementary students. However I do disagree for not having technologies early in education. If education have technology earlier, students would understand how to use the Internet and other important tasks. From personal experience, technology have enabled me to use computers in ways other people don't know how.

    I started learning to use computers around 8 years old, my parents bought a Windows 98 Gateway PC. 10 years ago this was like the best invention known to mankind. From then on I learned how to use the computer and learned to help do electronic paperwork for my family. Not only did I learn to write on the Internet, I also learned the basis of creating websites. Ever heard of xanga? It was like the Twitter of 2002. I would create my own mouse cursor, and have templates. By freshman year of high school I could have gotten a job in web design.

    The professional world is going to need people who are familiar with current day technology. You would be surprised by how many people who can't use antivirus (which are actually useless if you knew which directory is infected). By learning technology early, we develop computer skills that can be used for almost everyday.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I completely agree with the idea that elementary school children should have iPads to use as an educational tool. Technology like this has been proven to be easy for children to learn and develop skills with, which is a primary goal for the educational experience. Additionally, there is a bunch of information to be learned by these students that would otherwise not likely be accessed in the classroom by these students that can be presented in a new and fun way.
    The other part of this educational experience, which is that children need to interact with other children to build interpersonal skills, has become a concern with the implementation of such a technology. Children are still learning and developing their skills with this technology, though they are not getting the interaction that they should be getting from their peers and this can be seen as a major problem. According to “Being Human in the Age of the electronic Mob” by Lee Siegel, “[people] spend more time alone than ever before”. This is not a good this and should not be the effect of the use of iPads byt hese children.
    Like much technology that is out there today, there are pros and cons to this technology. Overall, I believe that it is more beneficial for these students to utilize this technology (and I also believe that this technology should be paid for by the government) rather than not, however, I also believe that there needs to be a balance between the usage of this technology and an interaction amongst students.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I know what you mean with all this technology. I don't think it is a smart move at all to introduce tablets and such to elementary schools. Middle school is also too early, in my opinion, for adding such devices for educational uses. Children in elementary school have no problem showing up to class; they think it is fun and aren't old enough to complain about how most of the classes are useless. Also, there are already enough people in the world complaining about ADD, do you think these new technologies would help that problem? I saw a commercial the other day advertising a tablet that is water resistant. They were trying to show that babies could play on it without the owner having to worry about it being ruined. Is this really where we wanted our technology to go to? Instead of painting, building things, or coloring in a coloring book, children now can just drag their finger across a screen. I’m sure children can learn from tablets to a certain extent, but there is no way to learn everything like that. Children need parenting and teachers. Giving your 3 year old a tablet with apps to teach them basic skills is not a healthy thing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It is crazy that kids in elementary school now have better phones then i do. I look at them in wonder. What in the world were their parents thinking when they bought them this iPhone? Its the same idea with the iPads. I didn't even have my own computer at that age. I probably barley knew how to work a computer. Every one before this decade has made it through schooling fine with out the technology we are handing to the children of this decade.
    I agree about the money. Every one is always complaining about money issues and how the taxes are too high. If schools are purchasing an iPad for every student in their school there is obviously going to be an increase in taxes. And on the other note about these children's parents, I'm almost positive they are not in favor of this idea.
    I also agree that a hands on task is much more effective then a task on the computer. Hands on tasks are a major asset to learning. Especially to a child in their elementary years. I also agree that handing a 5 year old an iPad is way too much. Those younger years of learning are essential to a child's future.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow to be honest I had not even thought about the financial side of technology in school systems. You bring up a very good point here, and I am interested as to what the parents, as well as other taxpayers, would have to say about school budgets also. There’s no way these things are being paid for with extra money because these things aren’t cheap. How much does an iPad run for? Multiply that number by at least 20, and that’s the cost for only one class. That is a ton of money that would probably be added to the school budget proposal. And do these kids really need an iPad when they can find the same information out of an old book or off the computer that the school already has? In other words, not needed.

      Delete