Monday, May 7, 2012

The Reproduction of Art


I am the type of person that enjoys art and its history, when I am bored at home sometimes me and my friends will even go to the local art museum just to spend time there and learn a few things. The most exciting thing to me about art though, is when you get to see an original piece, just everything is so different about it. There is a certain aura you get when seeing it, and the reproduction of that piece will never seem to have the same effect on a person no matter how good it is. I think of aura as a feeling you get from a piece of art, the mood of it and how you may be able to connect to the piece itself. When looking at a piece of original art, there is no denying that it is mesmerizing just because someone at one point actually sat down, and took time to paint what they were feeling most, and the way specific details were concentrated upon is amazing. I am in love with art, it is so important to me because there is always an interesting history behind it that I can learn from.
I may love the aura and feeling of an original piece of art but it is so hard for people to always see them. This is why I am not against mechanical reproduction, because the reproduction of a work of art is not a bad thing, it helps expand knowledge through out the world. If we didn’t have replicas of Van Gogh’s starry night or the Mona Lisa by Leonardo da Vinci, the majority of people in the world would never know what those pieces looked like, or the history behind them. I am against the idea that reproducing pieces of art will take away from aura and uniqueness. The original piece of art is unique in itself, because there is only one of them. But if a piece of art was not meant to be shared, then it would have never been seen by the public in the first place. If a piece of art is developed for people to see it, then the idea of reproducing it should not be seen as bad. Art is for sharing, its expressive and imaginative; there is no reason why it should be left for only a specific group of people should see it. The aura may not be the same as looking at the original piece, but it still exists. The uniqueness may not be there because it is a replica of the original, but the piece itself is still unique because no body will ever be able to produce a painting exactly the same as the original. Mechanical reproduction shares art and ideas, but it does not ruin the meaning of the painting itself.

6 comments:

  1. I completely agree with your post and I love the way described the aura of the art pieces. Humans have multiple different ways to release their emotions and thoughts in productive ways and it allows for the person to examine the thoughts in a deeper way. Personally, I get my feelings out by writing music; lyrics, guitar, piano, and basically whatever I feel will allow me to express the emotion I have bottled up inside me. Like you said, the art is meant to be shared because it represents what the painter was feeling and focused on and has a deeper meaning than just the look of the art itself. The same goes for music. Artists write music for their benefit and reproduction allows others to enjoy the work for themselves without needing to find "the original." Art is powerful, creative, and thought-provoking. It affects different people in different ways and people only enhance their knowledge by allowing it into their life. Without reproduction of art, this would too difficult. Naturally the aura will be diminished, but that doesn't change the meaning or impact the piece can have on an individual. Finally, seeing a reproduced copy of a work only makes it that much better when an individual gets to see the original.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Emily in regards to the mechanical reproduction of art destroying the aura of an original work of art. An original work of art is something that can never be reproduced. Like Emily mentions, Da Vinci’s Mona Lisa will never meet an equal in the aspect of artists recreating it. This extreme aura that is supposed to surround an original work of art is often lost in the mix in today’s culture. Printers, computers, and televisions have truly diminished the rarity of traveling to see one of these original works of art. People can now get wallpaper in a room with Mona Lisa’s face all over it. Computers allow people to photo shop images and re-create mostly any image. This is the attitude of the aura of original works of art now. People do not seem to comprehend the history that comes with an original work of art. Like people say “that’s my name don’t wear it out” is related to art. The mass reproduction of so many of these originals in different ways has definitely worn out their aura as if it was their name. I think mechanical reproduction has its benefits, but the negative effects of it though I feel are diminishing the aura of many works of art.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that Mechanically sharing does not affect the "Meaning" of the painting, or art in general. I put quotations around the word meaning because for the most part. The meaning of any work of art is subjective unless otherwise stated by the artist them self. With that being said a viewer could even disagree with the artist on what they think that the artist was implying. It seem idiotic to argue with an artist over the meaning of their work, but it just goes to show that different people have different opinion. Think about the "The Scream" painting. It has been around for a while and there are thousands of copy I'm sure, yet it was recently sold for near 120 million dollar. If someone still believes that paintings and art loses their aura with mass reproduction, then that person may not be convince-able. my main point here being that, while copies may lack authenticity and the value of the original, the original would not be as famous or special. Contrary to popular belief that with reproduction the original is is less valuable but it is not so and the fact that there are more copies add more aura to the original.

    ReplyDelete
  4. So true girl! You are right on the money when you say that a reproduction of a piece of artwork does not change the aura. I mean the numerical value may be different, obviously, because it is not an original, but when you view and observe a painting you see it as the entire overall portrait. You do not look closely to the type of paint or the thickness, rather how the colors are mixed and stroked. With this being said, it does not matter if it is the original or a reproduction because the meaning will not change.
    People are dumb for even thinking that a reproduction painting is worthless. Art is everything and anything. So for someone to degrade and criticize a copy of a piece that they would otherwise praise in an original, well that is bonkers. You know exactly what I mean because you even said that many people would never know what great artworks are out there if it were not for copies. Not everybody will have the chance to see the great Mona Lisa, but by making a copy you can share it with the world.

    -Monique Mitchell

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree that you get a certain aura from the original. Society must feel this way as well because if they didn't everybody would just go on vacations using google earth to travel around the world. There is something about seeing something in person then a computer generated version. Its also important to have copies or reproductions of the original because people woldnt know about the original if they didn't see the replica. For example how would people ever have a desire to go to the grand canyon if they never seen pictures of it? However its important to realize that you don't get the same feeling from looking at a picture of the grand canyon as you do as actually standing in the heat and looking at it. While I know this isn't exactly a perfect example because its not art by normal standards. You see my point.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I also agree that a piece of original artwork does have an aura about it. There is just something about being in the presence of an original that you can feel everything the mood the meaning. It is something that cannot be replicated when you see a replication or a copy of the original. I have been to many art museums and I know exactly what you are describing when you say when your actually there, it is not comparable. However, many people cannot get to see many pieces of artwork based on their location or the location of the piece of artwork. That is where replications come into play. I believe that with mass production it is very important to have because many famous pieces would not have been as popular or as well know without the spread of replications and copies of the original. Today many copies of artwork are spread everywhere from being tweaked and put into advertisements where they are recognizable or even in history books. The importance of having replications is very important to the original piece of work as well. It makes the spread of the popularity of the piece. Also, people that cannot go to see the original can actually see the piece by looking at a replication.

    ReplyDelete